Monna Giovanna and the mam of Bath space both fictional personalities in two separate works. Monna Giovanna, a personality in Decameron’s Federigo’s Falcon, is a beautiful noblewoman life in Florence with her husband and also son. She is gone after by another man, Federigo however being a virtuous and also fair woman, walk not give in come his advances. Through time, her husband passes away leaving his riches to her son who later falls sick. The child requests for Federigo’s falcon so as to get well and being a dedicated mother, Monna go to request Federigo for it. Unfortunately, Federigo has turned the falcon into a meal and also has nothing to provide Monna.
You are watching: What is your opinion of monna giovanna
Her son later dies leaving her a fortune and also to respect Federigo’s loyalty, she marries that (Boccaccio, Payne and also Cuilleanain 405-410). On the various other hand, the wife of bathtub is a character in the Canterbury tales and is the 6th tale. She tale has a rather long prologue and gives an account of she life. It appears to be a confession that the things she has done but at the very same time, she shows up to be trying to justify her actions (Moore). Compare OF MONNA GIOVANNI and also THE mam OF bathtub Monna Giovanna, a conformist, is more representative that the middle ages times 보다 the mam of Bath, a non- conformist.
Both characters appear to be more different than alike in character and also in their mindset towards life. Monna Giovanna is a wealthy noblewoman that portrays all the characteristics of a good woman together per the middle ages times. She is faithful and loyal to she husband in spite of Federigo’s developments and the book quotes her together being ‘no much less virtuous 보다 fair” (Boccaccio et al, 406). She faithfully observes the customizeds of the medieval times, moving into the country after the fatality of her husband and getting someone to accompany her as soon as she visits Federigo, exhibiting ‘womanly graciousness” (406-407).
On the various other hand, the mam of bathtub is no a well-off woman no one a beautiful one but she works tough to end up being one through her marriages to rich men. Unlike Monna, she is not a conformist come the medieval customs and also is stubborn, candid, complete of vitality and from she life’s account, not gracious in ~ all. She exposes intimate details concerning her private life fairly readily and also is also an extremely candid in her revelation of her worldly perspective towards religious activities (Moore). The two women have different mindsets towards men.
Monna remains devoted to her husband also as Federigo tries to woe she with presents (Boccaccio et al, 406) and when that dies, she would have preferred to continue to be alone but upon insistence from she brothers, decides to marry Federigo (410). ~ above the other hand, the mam of bathtub remarries every time she is widowed and has a total of five husbands who she tries to regulate (Moore). Thus while Monna believes in the leadership of the man, the wife of bathtub would rather exercise regulate over him and advises various other wives to carry out the exact same (Moore). The women also differ in their mindset towards marriage.
See more: Which Of These Is Most Closely Associated With Cultural Anthropology? ?
Monna Giovanna appears to organize marriage as a spiritual institution as she preserves it despite Federigo’s advances. She holds values such as loyalty and also love in high esteem together opposed come riches and also this drives her to get married Federigo in spite of his bad status, thinking that she would much rather “ have actually a guy with no riches than wealth without a man. ” (Boccaccio et al, 410). Monna seems to view marriage as a resource of companionship yet even as she states this, the mam of bath is ready to use marital relationship to acquire wealth and improve her standing in society. She choose old but wealthy husbands for product gain and also is quite proud that it.
She views marital relationship as a resource of pleasure rather than companionship and wealth shows up to be an ext important 보다 love. Hence after securing your wealth, she watch no require in continuing to shot winning their love (Moore). Middle ages women to be subordinated as portrayed by Monna yet the wife of bath manages come break away from this. Referrals Boccaccio, Giovanni, man Payne and Cormac O. Cuilleanain. Decameron. London, UK: Wordsworth Editions, 2004 Moore, Andrew Robert. The wife of Bath’s Prologue and also Tale-study guide. N. D. 12 Feb 2009