The expression “butter i will not ~ melt in his mouth” is among the most misunderstood paragraph in the English language. Some world think that is provided to mean that a human being is sweet and innocent whilst others are adamant the it way that a person is a manipulator or a liar. It appears a little surprising to uncover one phrase with such polar opposite interpretations. For this reason which is it? and what’s it acquired to carry out with butter melting? those the story behind the idiom “butter i will not ~ melt in your mouth”?

The original meaning of the phrase “butter i will not ~ melt in your mouth”

Originally, approximately 1530, the expression was much less obscure 보다 it may seem today, since when it first started gift used, it was directly related come a person having a cold, detached and also emotionless manner (where “cold” offered in this method is one older an allegory itself). The idea was that a person was therefore cold that his mouth was at a temperature in ~ which butter i will not ~ melt.

You are watching: Butter won t melt in your mouth

Evolution that the phrase

Throughout time the phrase “butter i will not ~ melt in his mouth” evolved.
from cold and also detached, it became used to refer to civilization who were prim and also proper, who acted by society’s rules regardless that their own feelings about any situation. (This neglect for your feelings is wherein the cold, emotionless next of the expression came right into the equation). Because that the objective of law the socially-determined “right” thing, girl may have actually pretended to be modest and also shy, or high culture men and women may have pretended to be interested in national politics or theatre or whatever society deemed together the “proper” things to it is in interested in.

This is wherein the confusion of this phrase began:

The definition of the phrase started to branch in 2 directions:

Butter wouldn’t melt in his mouth meaning “liar”:Some people started associating the phrase with phony civilization in culture who were placing on an act come fit in and also be watched favorably. Castle lied about their true feelings and also were because of this seen as insincere, liars or manipulators.


Butter i will not ~ melt in his mouth meaning “sweet and also innocent”:Other world focused ~ above the “prim and proper” nature that was a result of ignoring personal feelings because that the sake of fulfilling society’s expectations. Throughout much of history, it was the prim and proper thing, especially amongst young ladies, to appear sweet and also innocent; hence this new an interpretation became attached come the “butter wouldn’t melt in she mouth” phrase.When provided in this feeling however, over there is regularly a an unfavorable twist ~ above the phrase. When used to describe someone together sweet and innocent, that is almost always complied with by a “but”.A an excellent example the this can be seen in william Makepeace Thackeray’s Pendennis (1850): “When a visitor comes in, she smiles and also languishes, you’d think the butter i will not ~ melt in her mouth: <BUT> the minute that is gone, really likely, she flares up choose a tiny demon, and also says points fit come send you wild”.Over time, some world have forgotten the “but” and have started associating the expression with real sweet innocence, also though this no the strictly correct usage of the original phrase.In essence, both that these interpretations have some fact to them, but both interpretations only tell component of the entirety story. The full story is that “butter wouldn’t melt in her mouth” just if you space at some level exhilaration in a means which is cold and also detached from your true emotions.

Other short articles you might enjoy:Check the end our other etymology write-ups including:- Why execute we speak “eat your heart out”?- Why execute we someone has “egg on the face”?- Why execute we have the phrase “in a nutshell”?- Why carry out we say us tie the knot when we gain married?

Related Products


This entry to be posted in Etymology and also tagged etymology. Bookmark the permalink.

See more: 1998 Ford Windstar Transmission Range Sensor, How Do You Reset The Transmission Range Sensor is a participant in the Amazon services LLC Associates Program, one affiliate advertising program designed to carry out a way for sites come earn proclaiming fees by advertising and also linking to & As an Amazon Associate ns earn native qualifying purchases. This website is likewise an affiliate with Zazzle, and Cafepress, and runs adverts native Google Adsense. So please note that clickable pictures and also links top top this site may contain affiliate web links that help the website owner store this website running.